@filpi2. I have an answer for you as to what is going on.
It seems as though the problem is that IE9 is incompatible with mootools versions 1.1 and 1.2. If you click F12 and select “Console”, then refresh the page with the listing, you will see the following error come up: “SCRIPT5022: DOM Exception: INVALID_CHARACTER_ERR (5) mootools.js, line 1 character 21432”
Here is a discussion about the problem: http://mootools-users.660466.n2.nabble.com/Moo-mootools-and-ie9-some-relavant-bug-td6172026.html
Here is a possible solution: http://www.youjoomla.com/joomla-1.5-moo-1.2.4-and-ie9-bug-fix.html
So, the problem is not with my plugin, as you can see from the error itself and the same problem that others have experienced. Maybe you should consider to upgrade to Joomla 2.5 soon, since Joomla 1.5 will reach the end of its life in April 2012.
Anyways, I hope my analysis can help you.